A federal district court on Thursday, October 29th, struck down a key provision of the Trump administration’s Medicaid work requirement regulations, ruling that federal officials unlawfully narrowed exemptions for individuals with serious medical conditions and disabilities. The decision also provides temporary enforcement relief to 25 states and the District of Columbia as they prepare to implement the new requirements. The decision doesn’t apply to non-plaintiff states. While the decision will likely be appealed, this is an important victory for those states.  

U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns of the District of Massachusetts issued the ruling in Massachusetts v. Oz, a lawsuit challenging regulations issued by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, enacted in July 2025. The plaintiff states are: Massachusetts, California, New Jersey, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Hawai’i, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin. 

The legislation requires certain Medicaid expansion beneficiaries, generally adults ages 19 through 64, to complete 80 hours of work or community service monthly, or participate in qualifying educational activities, beginning January 1, 2027. Congress included exemptions for individuals considered medically frail or having special medical needs, including those with serious illnesses, disabilities, substance use disorders, and certain mental health conditions. 

However, CMS regulations issued in June introduced an additional eligibility condition. Individuals seeking a medical frailty exemption would also have to demonstrate that their condition significantly impaired their ability to satisfy the work requirements. 

The plaintiff states argued that this additional standard exceeded CMS’ statutory authority, imposed unnecessary administrative burdens, and threatened coverage for individuals Congress expressly intended to exempt. 

Judge Stearns agreed, concluding that Congress established specific categories of individuals who must qualify for the medical frailty exemption. Although CMS possesses authority to define medical frailty, the agency cannot impose additional restrictions that exclude individuals within those statutory categories. 

The court consequently vacated the challenged definition nationwide and permanently prohibited its enforcement against the plaintiff states. 

Importantly, the ruling also grants the plaintiff states a six-month stay of federal enforcement concerning medical frailty determinations. This relief provides additional flexibility as states update eligibility systems, verification processes, and administrative procedures necessary to implement the revised exemption standards. 

The decision doesn’t invalidate Medicaid work requirements or postpone their statutory January 1, 2027, implementation deadline. States must continue preparing to administer the broader requirements. 

The ruling also represents only a partial victory for the plaintiffs. Judge Stearns upheld two additional CMS provisions challenged in the lawsuit: a 12-month limitation on historical claims and encounter data used to verify medical frailty, and restrictions allowing only one self-attestation of medical frailty during a continuous enrollment period. Those provisions preserve significant documentation and verification responsibilities for state Medicaid agencies and beneficiaries. 

The decision carries substantial operational implications for state Medicaid programs. Officials must ensure that individuals meeting the statutory medical frailty categories are appropriately excluded from work requirements while maintaining compliant verification procedures. For Medicaid beneficiaries with serious health conditions, the ruling removes an additional barrier to obtaining an exemption.  

With the January deadline approaching, states must now reconcile the court’s decision with existing federal guidance while continuing preparations for one of Medicaid’s most significant eligibility changes in decades.

Topics: CMS, Medicaid